‘Godspell’ Review: Musical Theater Rises From the Dead – The New York Times

Front row, from left: Emily Koch, Isabel Jordan and Najah Hetsberger in the show, which is being presented under a tent behind one of the theater’s regular venues. Sara Krulwich/The New York Times

The Berkshire Theater Group put on the first professional musical in the U.S. since the pandemic lockdown, and itʼs a revival in every sense.

Read the article in The New York Times

By Ben Brantley

PITTSFIELD, Mass. — And it came about that the faith of the devoted was sorely tested during the months of famine, and there was a great hunger to believe again. Thus on a hazy night in August, several score of them gathered, with their lower faces hidden as the times demanded, in a parking lot in a small city in the lap of the Berkshire Mountains. They were looking for signs of a resurrection.

It felt right that a tent — with socially distanced folding chairs set up inside — had been assembled behind the Colonial Theater here, as if for a revival meeting. The 1971 musical “Godspell,” which was being reincarnated by the Berkshire Theater Group, is based on parables from the New Testament, and its leading man is named Jesus.

But the creed being promulgated so poignantly here, in a mood that might be described as highly creative caution, wasn’t so much Christianity as the embattled religion of theater, the practice of which has all but disappeared in the age of the Covid-19 pandemic.

The very existence of this version of John-Michael Tebelak and Stephen Schwartz’s half-century-old slice of story-theater uplift qualifies as something of a miracle. As a general rule, summer stagings of “Godspell,” a favorite of church and school theaters, are as common as crab grass. But this “Godspell” has historic singularity on its side. It is the first professional musical, sanctioned by Actors Equity, to open in this country since the great pandemic lockdowns began.

This means that the show, directed by Alan Filderman and choreographed by Gerry McIntyre, had to follow rules of Talmudic rigor, in compliance with the Massachusetts State Department of Health, to keep its 10-member cast and its 75-member audience safe from infection. Such dictums have been hard enough to enforce in supermarkets.

But in live theater, which relies on communal intimacy? And “Godspell,” which traditionally features sunny young casts cuddling and romping like a herd of puppies, is one of the huggiest musicals ever created.

That’s one of the reasons hardened critics have tended to sneer at “Godspell.” Check out the reviews that have appeared in The New York Times over the years, and you’ll find descriptions like “nauseating” (Clive Barnes, 1971); “recalls nothing so much as ʻThe Muppet Show’” (Bruce Weber, 2000), and “relentlessly perky” (Charles Isherwood, 2010).

But historical and social context counts for a lot in how a work of art is perceived. If you’ve been stranded in a desert with nothing to drink, a communion chalice of grape soda may taste like the finest Champagne. Having experienced theater only via computer screens for some 150 days, I was thirsty for any kind of in-person encounter with flesh-and-blood practitioners.

I hasten to add here that this “Godspell” isn’t just better than nothing. And it’s as deeply affecting as it is not despite, but because of, its well-worn material. In reimagining a string of biblical life lessons and folkified hymns and gospel songs for the age of the coronavirus, Mr. Filderman and company are speaking to contemporary fears bred by isolation and inaction.

The production begins with the cast members describing what their lives have been like during lockdown and the Black Lives Matter protests. (The original “Godspell” portrayed a battling dialogue of famous philosophers.)

They have all had their acting careers derailed, and they describe feelings of fear, even mortal fear, and hopelessness. And they worry that the theater they knew and lived by might indeed be a thing of the past.

Dressed not in the flower-child glad rags associated with the 1973 “Godspell” film but in Hunter Kaczorowski’s inventive variations on denim work and play clothes, they proceed not only to speak but to embody the show’s most crucial precept. You know, do unto others, etc.

The golden rule here takes the form of their nearly always keeping at least six feet from one another. Whenever they have to cross one another’s paths they make sure their masks (bunched around their necks) are pulled into place. When a chorus sings Schwartz’s tuneful earwig pop gospel — an activity known to let spittle fly — it does so behind the transparent panels of Randall Parsons’s beautifully utilitarian set. (Matthew E. Adelson’s patterned lighting helps keep it from looking like a doctor’s waiting room.)

Despite being part of a cast of 10, each performer is up there alone. They usually dance (even tap dance) in place, sometimes seated. (High points: Nicholas Edwards as Jesus and Tim Jones as Judas doing a vaudeville-style duet with yardsticks instead of canes, and lots of handsanitizing shtick, and Zach Williams vamping like a killer chorine from “Chicago.”) When the script calls for physical contact — which includes being baptized, embracing, slapping a cheek (so the other can be turned) and, of course, a Judas kiss — action and reaction are delivered in separate, distanced places.

As a metaphor for how so many of us have been living since March, this form of theatrical communication feels both heartbreaking and valiant. We adapt, we make do, even as we long to return to the age of the handshake and the hug.

This style of performance also has the advantage of scaling back the antic, exhibitionist quotient of “Godspell.” As in most latter-day productions, there are interpolated cute contemporary references (they here include Dad jokes and the Occupy movement). But there’s a new sense of reflectiveness here, and you actually feel you’re seeing the show’s precepts put into action.

Of course, the telling of the parables — the prodigal son, the good Samaritan — still fill lots of stage time, a bit tediously, with the performers adopting cute accents. It’s when the cast members, most of whom embody a multitude of roles, sang that I found my mandatory face mask was often wet with tears.

It’s not that all have exceptional voices (although Alex Getlin, doing “By My Side,” written by Jay Hamburger and Peggy Gordon, has an Orphic folk alto to melt stone). But they sing with clarity, conviction and a radiant gratitude for the chance to be there. And neither they nor Andrew Baumer’s musical direction ever push too hard for soul-rousing, hand-clapping effect (not even during the show’s breakout hit, “Day by Day,” sincerely sung by Isabel Jordan).

As for the man of the moment — or should I say of eternity? — Edwards’s open-faced Jesus is no holier-than-thou, preachy prophet. In song, he projects a beatified ambivalence that turns mixed feelings into a state of grace. His voice segues from burnished mellowness into a big, blazing brightness that’s always underscored with pain.

When he finishes singing the ballad “Beautiful City,” he looks both ravenously hopeful and devastated as he tries to envision a radiant future. I never thought I’d say this, but I know exactly how Jesus feels.

Plan Your Visit

Read our suggestions on where to dine, and where to hang your hat.

Get Started
Did You Know?
Just like NPR, Berkshire Theatre Group depends on the generous giving of its members!
Join Today!
We believe the performing arts can transform a community.
Learn More
Of the 16,000 Berkshire County school children, we serve 13,000 through our BTG PLAYS! Year-Round Educational Programs.
Learn More
Theatre is the place where we go to understand what lies in the human heart.
About Us
BTG's buildings, on two campuses in Stockbridge and Pittsfield, are historic treasures.
Theatre Info
Berkshire Theatre Group believes that the creative arts encourage freedom of speech and debate.
Get Involved
"Out of need will come the way. Once the pandemic ebbs, whenever that is, there will be an incredible need to gather again." - Artistic Director, Kate Maguire
Join Today!
The theatre has existed from the time of the Greeks. We will go on.
Learn More
Join Our Mailing List

Receive the latest BTG News, Updates, Special Offers, and more right to your inbox.

Subscribe

News & Articles

From the Archive: Eva LeGallienne

By: Katie Birenboim (She/Her/Hers)   Devoted fans of BTG may gasp to discover that until doing a first round of research in the amazing BTG archives, I had never heard … Read On

EXCITING NEWS! Join Magic Tree House series author Mary Pope Osborne and playwright Will Osborne for a book signing in The Garage from 1-1:45pm before the BTG Plays! performance of The Magic Tree House: Pirates Past Noon KIDS on February 15!

Books provided by The Bookloft in Great Barrington will be available for purchase in The Garage during the book signing.
36 0
✨ ATTENTION Matilda JR. auditionees! ✨ Directors David Adkins and Kathy Jo Grover want to remind you to please submit your completed forms to auditions@berkshiretheatre.org by midnight TOMORROW, February 2 to be completely registered for auditions.

Thank you, and we look forward to seeing you soon!
88 0
There are still a few spots left for Acting Through Song!, a two-day workshop led by Michael Wartella (BTG Artistic Associate, Broadway actor and musician) that will take participants' acting, singing and performance skills to the next level for actors ages 12-18 of all levels. To register and learn more, please email allison@berkshiretheatre.org

February 8th & 9th from 12pm-4pm
The Colonial Theatre (111 South Street, Pittsfield, MA)
$25
48 0
BTG PLAYS! Year Round Education Program is excited to announce Acting Through Song!, a two-day workshop led by Michael Wartella (BTG Artistic Associate, Broadway actor and musician) that will take participants' acting, singing and performance skills to the next level for actors ages 12-18 of all levels.

February 8th & 9th from 12pm-4pm
The Colonial Theatre (111 South Street, Pittsfield, MA)
$25

To register and learn more, please email allison@berkshiretheatre.org.
42 0
BTG is seeking young actors currently in grades 3–12 to audition for its upcoming non-Equity youth production of Roald Dahl’s Matilda The Musical JR. Auditions will be held at The Colonial Theatre on Monday, February 10 from 6–9pm and callbacks are scheduled for Tuesday, February 11 from 6–9pm.

Appointments and registration are required by February 2 to audition, so please email auditions@berkshiretheatre.org to book a time slot. To learn more, visit berkshiretheatregroup.org/casting-auditions/
71 0
"Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that." -Martin Luther King Jr.

Today, in honor of Martin Luther King Jr.'s legacy, our offices will be closed. Everyone at BTG continues to be inspired by his words and deeds as we move forward in the world.
34 0
Check out all that BTG has in store for February! From dynamic tribute bands to family friendly fun, we have a wide variety fit for everyone.

To purchase tickets and look at our full 2025 season calendar, visit berkshiretheatre.org.
49 0
Happy New Year from all of us at Berkshire Theatre Group! ✨🎇
38 0
Still looking for plans to celebrate the new year? Join BTG as we celebrate 2025 with one of Berkshire County's favorite bands, Max Creek!

To purchase tickets, visit berkshiretheatre.org.
16 0
Happy Holidays from all of us at Berkshire Theatre Group! ✨❄ Take a look back at BTG's 2024 season with us in our snow globe as we look forward to celebrating the new year and beyond with you.
62 0
Don't wait! Buy your tickets now to take advantage of BTG's advance ticket discount for New Year's Eve with Max Creek! In addition, patrons attending the concert can add a room at a special discounted rate at The Holiday Inn, located on 1 West Street, Pittsfield!

To learn more and purchase tickets, visit berkshiretheatre.org.
8 0
Attention: For the holiday season, BTG’s box office will be closed on 12/24, 12/25, 1/1, 1/5 and 1/12. Additionally, the box office staff will be working remotely 1/2 through 1/17.

Tickets can still be purchased at berkshiretheatre.org at any time. Thank you for your understanding!
14 0
Looking for gift ideas for the theatre lovers in your life? 🎁 BTG gift certificates are perfect for those looking to experience high quality performance art, whether it be theatre, concerts or anything in between! ✨

To purchase gift certificates, please visit berkshiretheatregroup.org/dining-lodging-services/gift-certificates/
15 0
BTG had the pleasure of celebrating Representative William “Smitty” Pignatelli (@repsmitty) with his friends and family at Saturday night's performance of A Christmas Carol for his the 22 years served in supporting and representing the 3rd Berkshire District. 

Thank you for giving the Berkshire community your endless hard work and dedication, Smitty!
85 0
New year, new shows! ✨ BTG just announced nine brand new shows for the 2025 winter and early spring season, so take a look at what is coming soon and purchase your tickets today at berkshiretheatre.org!
36 0
Follow Us